100 Scariest Movie Moments: #89 Alice, Sweet Alice

I’m uncertain if the title of Alice, Sweet Alice was intended to be ironic, or if the movie was named by marketing people who’d never actually seen it. Given that the original title was Confession, I find the latter explanation more plausible. The movie was re-released two years after its initial premiere to cash in on Brooke Shields' popularity.

Shields plays Karen, the younger sister of the eponymous Alice (Paula Shepard). Karen is better behaved, and the favorite. Alice, feeling unloved, acts out, stealing from Karen and generally being a little bitch. Then, Karen is killed at her first communion and Alice is found with her veil, leading to the suspicion that Alice is the killer. It certainly doesn’t help her case that her hated aunt is then attacked by someone in a raincoat and a mask identical to a mask Alice wore earlier in the film to scare her sister.

It’s a bit difficult to pin down the exact protagonist of the film. A great deal of screen time is given to Alice, but we’re never given a great deal of insight into her mind. We also see her parents (Niles McCaster and Linda Miller) and the police trying to understand what’s going on.

The fact that Alice is innocent is a foregone conclusion. She’s clearly a red herring, and who the actual murderer is seems largely unimportant to me. The movie is an exercise in empathy, intended to make you feel as miserable as possible for all of the characters. Everyone speaks slowly with many sighs, unless they are yelling. Alice creates havoc wherever she goes. Hell, they make the landlord (Alphonso DeNoble) a fat pedophile just in case a murdered child wasn’t sufficient.

We are led for a while to believe that Alice is insane. Under a lie detector, test it comes out that she believes her sister attacked her aunt. She clearly believes that Karen is punishing her from beyond the grave. Whether that punishment is for being a bully, or being a murderer is the real question.

This movie is indeed extremely scary, but it’s quite difficult to pin down why. The attacks themselves? The death of a child? The threat of Alice being institutionalized? The fat pedophile? In general they all seem to combine into a sense that the universe is a miserable place to live in, and life is nothing but suffering.

The final shot of the movie seems to imply that Alice, while not guilty of the murder of her sister, is in fact destined to become a murderer herself anyway. She’s shown with the knife of the killer, which she conceals in a shopping bag, and examines with a resolved face.

So, life sucks, and then you become a murderer. There is no escaping, and there is no happy ending. The movie's constant use of religious imagery against such a tragic story underscores this idea, with religion serving merely to help these poor, deluded fools move on with their lives. The killer, before being taken away by the police, demands communion, and stabs the priest when he refuses to give it to her. The movie could almost be called Lovecraftian thematically, even lacking any supernatural elements.

The movie, while cheap, is effective. It feels a bit assembly-line, as if the director wasn't so much telling a story as designing a product specifically to manipulate the emotions of his audience. That said though, it worked. So, yes, this movie is definitely worth checking out.