I'm hoping that I'll eventually
encounter an individual Goosebumps
episode that wouldn't have worked better as a two-parter.
Unfortunately, that seems unlikely when they're boiling down a
100-page book to just 20-minutes. Piano Lessons Can be
Murder certainly fits into that
category, as it tries to combine both a ghost and evil robots into a
single story.
That
said, however, I'm really not sure that this is a story that deserved
two parts. It isn't horrible in concept, but it's also less
memorable than you'd expect for such a story. I can safely say that
I would sacrifice this episode for a second half of The
Phantom of the Auditorium.
Jerry (Ben Cook), a
kid with few friends and a big imagination moves into a new house
with a piano in the basement. Jerry develops a crush on a local girl
named Kim (Erica Luttrell, kudos for the interracial romance) with an
interest in music, and decides that he wants to learn to play to
impress her. However, the Ghost of a former music teacher who lived
in his house (Brenda Devine) warns him to “stay away” from the
Shreek School, where he gets his parents to sign him up for piano
lessons.
Dr. Shreek (Aron
Tager) is a strange man, with a weird obsession with hands, who
employs a maintenance main named Mr. Toggle (Geza Kovacs).
Eventually, Dr. Shreek tries to take Jerry's hands, only to be shut
off by Mr Toggle, who as it turns out is a robotics genius who built
Dr. Shreek and various other piano-playing robots...and Mr. Toggle
then tries to take his hands because robotic hands are hard to build.
However, the ghost comes, revealing that Toggle had been a student
of hers (she claims he was lazy, he claims she was too demanding),
and for attacking Jerry the teacher traps Toggle in the school and
forces him to practice for all eternity. Jerry gives up on the
piano.
I run through the
plot quickly to make my point: All of this material might have worked
if there was proper time for build-up. Most of the actors are pretty
good, and Jerry is one of the more memorable protagonists from this
show. Rather than being a bland everykid, he constantly narrates
imaginary adventures the instant he's out of earshot of an adult (and
sometimes within).
However, the
characters other than Jerry seem to get only two, perhaps three
scenes. Dr. Shreek gets one scene teaching Jerry the piano, and
throwing in a comment about how his own hands don't “work like they
used to” as blatant foreshadowing, and a scene of him going crazy.
Mr Toggle, likewise, gets his introduction where he shows off his
robotic floor sweeper, and says that he “programmed” Shreek to
call him a genius, the scene of his own breakdown, and the final
scene of him being forced to play.
Most notably, Kim
gets her introduction, and then returns at the end of the episode.
Apparently it would be too much to remind the audience of why Jerry
wanted to take piano lessons in the first place. If she couldn't be
worked into the story, then her presence probably wasn't necessary.
It's not like parents have ever needed a reason to put a kid with
minor problems in piano lessons.
The ghost is the
one element that does work. I'm not sure if it's the repeat
appearances throughout the episode, or just the actress, but whenever
she's onscreen warning Jerry that he's in danger I feel the tension.
The ghost is also fairly unique, neither falling into the cliches of
the harmless, helpful ghost, nor the purely wrathful. She clearly
has a moral compass, and cares about Jerry even as a boy with no
particular connection to her. Her motivations remains surprisingly
human.
That said, it's
clear you don't want to get on her bad side. She's a strict
disciplinarian, and is apparently prepared to stay with Toggle
forever to make sure he's suitably punished. I’m not sure of the
creative process that went into this spirit, and I kind of suspect it
was a simple “we need to make the ghost scary,” but what we got
by design or accident was good.
The
revelation that Toggle was the true villain worked, but having him
shut down Shreek ruined the whole effect. Either Shreek should be
working for him at the end, or Toggle should have motivations at
least slightly different from those of his creation. As it plays
now, the scene is awkward. They
basically took one villain out of the story to replace him with
another, effectively identical villain.
Even
so, they were good villains. This is hardly the only time this
series gave pedophillic undertones to it's villains (hell,
it’s more rare for the villains not to
have them), but the decision
to have them obsessed with a young boy's body-part seems like the
kind of thing the studio would likely forbid today. It’s
legitimately unsettling.
More
than one source on the internet have noted that this is the rare
episode without a twist ending. That seems to be more-or-less true.
The revelation of Toggle's punishment was, according to the
Goosebumps Wiki, not
in the book, but it's not really surprising once he was taken by a
piano teacher. Ironically, it still managed to be more frightening
than many of the actual twists. Playing
piano for the rest of eternity, kept alive by magical forces? Or
continuing as a ghost? Not a way I’d like to spend my time.
I don't exactly
recommend the episode. It has all the parts for several good
stories, but it's nothing special in and of itself. It seems like a
waste of a lot of talent, and a number of good ideas.
No comments:
Post a Comment